Contact Us

Beiler Insurance Agency, Inc.

5406 Lincoln Highway
PO Box 189
Gap, PA 17527

Phone: 717-442-9234

Fax: 717-442-9089

Hours: Mon-Fri 8-5, Sat by appt only.

Email Directory

Rob Beiler, Agency Owner & President

Chris Beiler, Owner & Vice-President

Paula Diem, Office Manager - Account Specialist

Dianne Kreiser, CSR - Accounting

Kelly Neff, Receptionist/Customer Service Agent

Mitch Weidman, Commercial, Personal, Life Agent

Margie Fisher Ingles, Life & Health Agent

Our Team of Professionals

Rob Beiler, Owner & President

Rob Beiler, born and raised in the Lancaster County Gap PA area, has dedicated his career to serving the community while owning and managing the insurance agency. Born on a farm, Rob raised hogs for a number of years and entered the insurance industry in 1989. He managed a small mutual insurance company before it was merged into Goodville Mutual Casualty Co in 1997. He became the Farm Underwriter at Goodville and was employed there until purchasing the Ardrey Insurance Agency along with his brother Clair Beiler in 2004. Clair has since retired from the agency and is the owner of Lancaster Awards and Apparel.

Rob is actively involved with the Gap Fire Co. serving as a volunteer in many capacities. Many times when the call comes in for help, Rob will jump up from his desk and go to the fire station to help someone in need and many times the ones in need can be our insurance clients. Linda & Rob have 3 children & enjoy time spent with them and the grandchildren. He enjoys spending time at the family hunting cabin in the North Country planting trees & crops for wildlife and managing the forest.

Chris Beiler, Owner & Vice-President

Commercial Lines Manager

Chris Beiler has been a licensed insurance agent since January of 2005, and joined BIA as a full time producer in January of 2008. After graduating from high school in 1996, he spent the next 12 years in the construction and building industry. The time spent in several jobs in those fields has proved to be beneficial in his role as a commercial producer in the insurance industry. Chris purchased his share of the agency upon Clair Beiler's retirement at the beginning of 2014.

Chris and his wife Megan, along with their three children, live on the outskirts of Gap. Chris volunteers at the Gap Fire Company, and is actively involved with his role as a captain and president of the company. He enjoys spending his free time with his family, golfing, playing sports, hunting, and cheering on the Philly sports teams.

Paula Ardrey Diem, CISR-Account Specialist Agent

Paula Ardrey Diem, was born and raised in Lancaster County in Gap PA. She started working for her father's insurance agency, Ardrey Insurance Agency, Inc, when she was just 16 years old. Paula has been serving our clients since then. Paula holds a CISR (Certified Insurance Service Representative) designation. She sells both personal and commercial insurance as well as hard to place insurance coverage. However, if asked what here favorite part of selling insurance is, "I would have to say, helping people understand what insurance is, how it works, and what their needs are, and how they can afford it".

Paula and Brian have one child & 2 granddaughters. When not working, you will find Paula volunteering in the community. She is the coordinator of Project Undercare; a grassroots group that provides underwear and personal hygiene items to underpriviledged children in the area. Her hobbies include photography, crafts, cooking, reading and sewing.

Dianne Kreiser, Customer Service Agent

Dianne Kreiser has been with the agency for 15 years. She serves as a receptionist and customer service representative / agent taking care of our clients. In addition to answering phones and greeting clients, Dianne also takes care of many things such as payments, endorsements, re-quoting and whatever else may come along.

Dianne & her husband Jeff enjoy spending time with their children & grandchildren. They enjoy spending time at their cabin in Huntingdon County. Dianne enjoys gardening, reading and the beach. She is also a Sunday School teacher and involved in activities at church

Marjorie Ingles, Producer-Life & Health Agent

Marjorie Ingles joined our sales team in 2004 and specializes in Life, Health and Employee Benefits. She takes pride in helping clients obtain quality and affordable insurance for whatever stage of life they are in. Margie has spent most of her life in Gap, PA. She is married to Lewis and they have 2 children. She became a licensed Agent in 1990 to help her husband with his business.

A member of Bellevue Presbyterian Church, she is on the Membership and Evangelism Committee and plays in the Hand Bell Choir. She has been a Lancaster County GOP Committee person and serves on the Pequea Valley Library Board of Directors. Margie enjoys fine dining and playing golf.

Kelly Neff, Account Specialist Agent

Kelly Neff joined the agency in 2012, and works to assist customers in both personal and commercial lines. She graduated from Harrisburg Area Community College with an Associate’s Degree in Business Management and has worked in sales since that time. Kelly is the daughter of Rob & Linda Beiler and she continues the tradition of the company being a "family run organization."

Kelly is a graduate of Pequea Valley High School and enjoys spending time at the beach or up in the mountains. Kelly & Darren are members at Grace Point Church and reside in Paradise, PA with their two daughters.

Mitch Weidman, Commercial, Personal, Life Agent

Mitch joined our sales team in 2016 as a Commercial Insurance Producer. He graduated from Millersville University with a Bachelor of Business Administration. Mitch lives in West Chester PA and has past experience in insurance sales. He has had experience in community outreach programs including involvement with Big Brothers/Big Sisters.

Mitch loves Philly sports and grew up playing baseball & football at Elizabethtown High School in Lancaster County. Mitch & Emily enjoy relaxing at Ocean City NJ beaches and spending time with his rescue dog, “Oakley.”

Emily Stoltzfus, Customer Service Rep

Emily joined the agency in 2017 and spends her time here answering the phones and providing customer service to our clients. Before joining the agency, Emily worked at Pequea Valley High School as a paraeducator and a Junior High Girls Basketball Coach. In her spare time, Emily enjoys spending time with her husband, Mike, and their rescue dog “Nora.” Mike and Emily are members at Mt. Zion United Methodist Church.